It is quite a show of confidence to make a list and title it "The Best American Poetry of the 21st Century (So Far)" The "so far" is more of a nod to so much century yet to come, rather than an acknowledgement of the tricky task of saying what are "the 25 most consequential collections from the past 25 years."
I'm not a fan of "best" lists, but they can be a good starting place for arguments and also as a guide to poets to sample. I have read nine of these collections, but I only own one. Poets are supposed to buy other poets' books, but I just don't want more books in the house. I love books, and it pains me to give away ones I have, but the reality is that I'm never going to read 90% of them again. There are ones I bought and never finished or even started reading! I'm in that phase of life when you are getting rid of things.
The one book from the list I own is The Shadow of Sirius by W. S. Merwin. I don't know that it is the best of the best on this list (which puts it down at #23), but it was one I read parts of in a bookstore and wanted to take home.
The article describes it like this:
"Merwin implores us to see that “the past is not finished / here in the present / it is awake the whole time.” The poet’s recollections include the texture of his mother’s hand at the piano, the image of an old dog running in the hills “like an unmoored flame,” the graciousness of a roofer named Duporte, now long dead. But the act of remembering always takes place amid natural as well as personal history: Merwin’s poetry has an ecological awareness that he sharpened through decades of work restoring and conserving palm trees in Hawaii. His careful stewardship of local flora helps make these poems’ descriptions—of the passing days and returning seasons; of birds and trees; of his wife, Paula, and the life they made together—tangible. That same tactile quality is what makes these verses’ sadness at the finality of loss so pointed."
Still, such a list, carefully made and annotated, is an invitation to read a poet that you have never read before, or a collection by a favorite that you missed.
Follow this blog for all things poetry.
To see our past prompts and more than 300 issues,
visit our website at poetsonline.org



